no no no no no! not the controllers. My friend got screwed, and, sorry to say, but u did too. Some of the ELITES are known to have action defects with games. My friend had the exact same problem with his 360 elite. They didn't return them because it was random... I have one idea, though. If you could make a lame excuse to switch with another copy, it might be of use. U coud try both the console or the game. That's all i got...:waves: